Haunted by the memory of Walter Holderlin, a soldier he killed during World War I, French musician Paul Renard (Phillips Holmes) confesses to a priest (Frank Sheridan), who grants him absolution. Using the address on a letter he found on the dead man's body, Paul then travels to Germany to find his family.
As anti-French sentiment continues to permeate Germany, Dr. Holderlin (Lionel Barrymore) initially refuses to welcome Paul into his home, but changes his mind when his son's fiancée Elsa identifies him as the man who has been leaving flowers on Walter's grave. Rather than reveal the real connection between them, Paul tells the Holderlin family he was a friend of their son, who attended the same musical conservatory he did.
Although the hostile townspeople and local gossips disapprove, the Holderlins befriend Paul, who finds himself falling in love with Elsa (Nancy Carroll). When she shows Paul her former fiancé's bedroom, he becomes distraught and tells her the truth. She convinces him not to confess to Walter's parents, who have embraced him as their second son, and Paul agrees to forego easing his conscience and stays with his adopted family. Dr. Holderlin presents Walter's violin to Paul, who plays it while Elsa accompanies him on the piano.
The film's original title, The Man I Killed, was changed to The Fifth Commandment to avoid giving "wrong impressions in the minds of the public about the character of the story." It ultimately was released as Broken Lullaby.
东映做皮套是真的抠
感觉剧情还不错，但是拍的很赶，很多背景没交代清楚甚至一笔带过，好在还算流畅，原班人马回归而且十年了居然都没怎么变，这实在是很惊喜，和TV版相互对应，中间的哭戏很感人，永恒结婚鸟皮套很帅，TV最后映司的意难平变成了剧场版Ankh的意难平，而Ankh的意难平又变成了我的意难平，对于从10年开始一集一集追的粉丝真的太刀了，东映明明可以拍的更好，但还是有不少遗憾，整体瑕不掩瑜吧，四星，多一星是很感恩ooo还能在10年之后拥有这样一部电影。
他抓住了他的手，他牺牲了自己，这次只是换了另一人牺牲，用自己的终末迎接他的新生。
就凭刀了映司，给一星完全是因为不能打负分……
可费了我期待这么久，映司的演技浪费了，毛利老贼，我写都比你写得好
好不容易演员全回归，就不能拍长点吗。拍的这是啥啊，非要整个映司死的，哎，本来10周年完全可以写个完美大结局吧。
醞釀了這麼多年，醞釀一把好大的刀，直接插進胸口還狠狠地轉他個好幾圈。在電影院裡的廁所平復情緒，仍組織不了什麼語言，我心死了。劇 透就是居然有聡哥來配音….エモ，但……媽的我心死了，什麼都拯救不了我。それでもやっぱね、これぞOOO、もう、大好き。
剧情也就那样吧，毕竟看的也不是剧情是情怀了，配合原作最后一集食用更佳。
时长太短，文戏太少，特效寒酸，导致显得仓促至极，就像高速走马灯风风火火赶着去坟里躺一样。TV有一个缺憾美却留有希望的结局其实很好，完全可以不拍续集，要拍就拍大团圆，就当圆梦，何必如此狗尾续貂去榨干最后一滴价值呢？
毛利… 我杀了你…😭😭 先婚后葬 你tnnd干得好啊😭
入坑作，对他的期望一直很大，tv结局其实已经够好的了，现在整的人鬼情未了，我以前看到各种这个剧场版混剪，看着主骑二骑皮套巨帅，还各种期待剧情打斗和特效，真的东映。。。boss皮套换色我习惯了，强行煽情了后面，boss出场交代不清楚，其他人包括主角都死的很潦草，他们俩要死要活的，我觉得一起死还更能接受。
十年前给我带来了遗憾，十年后给我带来了心绞痛。
太短了！太短了！太短了！就算是加上网络版的剧情也太短了，整部片子的开头就是仓促的人物出场，然后制造冲突，虽然剧情发展很理所当然，但是留白的空间太多，而且整篇描写映司的篇幅太少了，主角直接变工具人，这合理吗？最后，结局也没有升华，就草草了结，并且，真的有必要写死主角吗？太离谱了，想给一星，但是OOO本篇又是一部优秀的作品，为了情怀，只能稍微加点了。
刀得太狠了。这就10年了，我的平成新十年最爱
我真的真的好喜欢好喜欢OOO，我还能看到未来的剧情吗？还是真的就戛然而止了😭
可能是情怀党吧，我更喜欢tv结局一点，原来看ooo的时候还是初中，我记得整体感觉是偏欢乐的，这次体验就像看了武林外传的电影版一样，不知道狗尾续貂恰不恰当
没有小林靖子的ooo只能说是低劣的仿制品。整部剧场版就透露着贫穷这两个字，对十周年的纪念作我怎么就抱有期待呢！和朋友吐槽觉得最好看的是几段回忆杀直接放了tv片段，哭死我了并不是因为这部剧场版有多好看，而是我还在小林病院就没出来过…
感觉这部电影还是太短了，但是安库和映司真的让我好感动。为什么不能两个人都留下来，哭了(இωஇ )
观感如下：
三年前以为结局在平成final，结果是龙套
Copyright © 2015-2023 All Rights Reserved
